He starts by saying that "Those are the players MLS needs to keep or go
out and get, the players who might be great stars one day, but right now
are simply solid role players who increase the team competence on the
field." No one can argue with that statement, clearly any sports
league needs a healthy mix of rookies, solid supporting players, and
stars. But then, he makes a statement that I just can't process, and
if you look closely, contradicts itself quite obviously.
MLS doesn't need to pay them more money, but they do need to pay them
just enough to keep them here, something they have yet to do as a
corporate directive.
OK, so players are leaving because they can make more money overseas.
MLS needs to keep these players, presumably because they don't pay them
enough. But to keep them the league "doesn't need to pay them more
money"? Unless the league convinces the players to use some new sort
of math where the difference between what they make here and what they
could make elsewhere, which is negative, actually means they make more
money - why should a player stay with MLS? For the prestige and honor
of playing in the Champions Cup, Interliga, and maybe the Copa
Sudamericana?
It's easy to spend other people's money, particularly when they are
billionaires who own sports teams. What we are seeing this
off-season are the effects of tensions that have been in the league
putting the squeeze on the "Middle Class" player. Because it IS
happening more and also because the league is covered more in depth than
it was just a few years ago.
Can we conclude that the MLS business plan is predicated on building a
team based on a few star players, a sprinkling of supporting players,
and a higher-than-most-of-us-would-like reliance on raw, young players?
I think so. With the labor agreement in place through 2010 (Soccer Insider),
the owners have little incentive to raise their labor costs across the
board. Of course, more money is coming into the league thanks to team
operated stadiums, and TV rights fees. Come 2010, this could setup a
tense negotiation of the next labor agreement, players will look to get
a bigger share of, hopefully, a much bigger pie. Until then, we'll
keep watching some players leave (Dempsey), others return (Reyna), and
why some go play in the USL (Mctavish).